I received an email from Google complaining about this:
I have to say that I didn't add any new content/assets to my app since a while, I just made some fixes and improvements and now I'm getting this. Not sure what is this issue about. The took like half a month to review this versions.
They also mentioned this:
About the News policy Apps that select the ‘News’ category but exhibit content that does not meet these requirements are not permitted in the News category of the Play Store. News apps that require a user to purchase a membership must provide a content preview for users prior to purchase.
This issue could be happening because in the "App Content" section, when getting a Content Rating, you could have selected the "News" category.
This is the category selection in the "App Content" > "Content ratings" Section:
Also there is another option - "News Apps" - in the "App Content" section which looks like this:
Please check what option you have selected here, as I believe this is where the issue is.
It was on Finance category all the time and this has never been changed. I uploaded doces of updates of this app already. I'm starting to think that this is something more related to the new Google Play Console update
Updated question with info
Sorry, but you are talking about a different category (Store Category) than I am. I am talking about the "Content ratings" Category in "App Content". Can you add a screenshot of what option you chose in this selection? I have added a screenshot to my answer of what this section looks like.
We've found the problem! Thanks for the upvote and accepted answer :)
Yes, when you add the news section, you will have to select yes on that option. But after you select that, you will have to make sure you follow the policies here: support.google.com/googleplay/android-developer/answer/9949730